Important Notice:
This site has moved to, please update your bookmarks. If you were looking for a specific post, you can use the site search option or archives at the new domain to find it. Thank you!

Monday, April 04, 2011

Why Is the Recruiter an Idiot?

Dear Evil HR Lady,

I am curious as to why companies have people who have no idea what a position does conduct 1st round telephone interviews? Makes the job hunting process even more frustrating.

There are two answers to this question: One nice and one not so nice. Let’s start with the answer that gives recruiters and companies the benefit of the doubt.

Why Is the Recruiter an Idiot?


white Eagle said...

good say... i believe 2nd view is somewhat right...

Charles said...

Forget the recruiter or HR rep for a moment; How about the idiot managers who don't know what they are looking for?

I'm a trainer - not exactly a dime-a-dozen position at most organizations. So, unless they deal specifically with trainers all the time they really don't have a clue.

Most of the interviews that I have been to I felt like sending them a bill afterwards for my consultation fee - that is to say they had no clue as to what to ask, nor how to interview for a trainer, nor what even makes a good trainer. Something that many admit up front. "Gee, we've never hired a trainer before, so we are not sure what to look for." So, I feel like I have spent the interview "educating" them on what makes a good trainer.

How about the organization/hiring manager/HR rep/Recruiter/ all do their homework before wasting the job seekers time?

Anonymous said...

Job seekers might do well to remember that, bad or good, recruiters are a gatekeeper into the company. More often than not, even if we don't know every detail of the day-to-day of every job, we do know the general characteristics the company values and are looking for that -- you could say we're making sure YOU'RE not an idiot!